
Survey Results
Portfolio Health Check
Mark Isbitts
Insights
If you found yourself nodding along to several of these scenarios, you’re in good company. Most product organizations struggle with some version of these issues—too many ideas, unclear priorities, bloated portfolios, and a vision that’s more fog than roadmap. The details differ, but the themes are remarkably consistent.
What matters most isn’t whether you said “Absolutely” or “Never” to any given scenario—it’s recognizing the patterns. By collecting these responses, we can spot the underlying causes: lack of focus, weak decision frameworks, or simply too many cooks in the kitchen.
The good news? These are fixable problems. With the right clarity, structure, and discipline, teams can stop treading water and start moving the business forward.
Recommendations to consider
Your Score
22 out of 56
We asked:
Please help us understand your situation by responding to this quick survey. You should be able to respond in only a few minutes (if you don’t think too much about it).
Your responses
Challenges
Project versus product
1
.
My team is confused about the difference between a project and a product.
Your response: Somewhat
This confusion is more common than anyone wants to admit. A project is a temporary effort: it has a clear start, a defined end, and usually a small celebration when it’s done. A product, on the other hand, doesn’t really “end.” It’s a living thing that evolves, adapts, and—if well managed—continues to deliver value for years. Projects deliver outputs, while products deliver outcomes. When teams confuse the two, they start treating launch day as the finish line instead of the starting gun, which leads to abandoned products and disappointed customers.
Challenges
What to build
2
.
My team is unsure about what we should build and what we should avoid.
Your response: Absolutely
When there’s no clarity, every new request looks like a candidate for the backlog. The problem is that not every idea deserves your time or investment. Product management isn’t about collecting a long list of possible features; it’s about focusing resources where they matter most. Teams that don’t establish clear criteria end up chasing shiny objects, wasting effort, and frustrating engineers, executives, and customers alike. Strong product leaders know that clarity about what not to build is just as important as clarity about what to build.
Challenges
Too many ideas
3
.
We have too many ideas and don’t know which to choose.
Your response: Absolutely
Ideas are plentiful—everyone from the CEO to the intern has them. The challenge is filtering the signal from the noise. Without a disciplined prioritization process, teams either freeze in endless debates or try to tackle everything at once, burning out in the process. The best organizations use structured methods to weigh impact, evidence, alignment, and timing. That way, the ideas that move forward are backed by reasoning, not politics or volume. The rest aren’t discarded, just parked until the right moment.
Challenges
Too many products
4
.
We have too many products and want to keep the best and retire the rest.
Your response: Absolutely
Most portfolios eventually bloat. Every product added feels like progress at the time, but over the years you’re left with a cluttered mix of winners, laggards, and zombies. Keeping everything alive spreads resources thin and drains focus. Retiring products is rarely popular—customers complain, sales resists, and executives sometimes cling to “their” products—but avoiding the decision is worse. The healthiest companies prune intentionally, focusing resources on the strongest performers and letting go of the rest before they drag the business down.
Challenges
Vision
5
.
Our lack of vision has been embarrassing in front of leadership and customers.
Your response: Not so much
Few things damage credibility faster than stumbling when someone asks, “Where is this product headed?” Without a vision, teams drift, leaders lose confidence, and customers start shopping for alternatives. Vision doesn’t need to be lofty prose—it just needs to be clear, directional, and believable. It tells people why the product exists, where it’s going, and why anyone should care. Without it, your roadmap is indistinguishable from a random to-do list, and your strategy sounds like “whatever comes next.”
Challenges
Competition
6
.
We just acquired our biggest competitor. Now we have duplicate products and are struggling to rationalize the portfolio.
Your response: Never
Acquisitions look glamorous in press releases, but in the trenches, they’re messy. Suddenly you’ve inherited duplicate products, competing roadmaps, and two sets of customers convinced their product should win. Rationalizing that portfolio isn’t about compromise—it’s about making the hard calls quickly and communicating them clearly. Delay drives up costs, confuses customers, and creates internal turf wars. Success comes from assessing overlaps, sunsetting wisely, and focusing on a single, stronger portfolio that actually makes sense in the market.
Challenges
Saying No
7
.
We rarely say “no” to new product or feature ideas from customers, executives, salespeople, and others.
Your response: Somewhat
Every request feels urgent in the moment, but saying “yes” to everything is the fastest way to kill a product. A product crammed with disconnected features becomes confusing to customers and unmanageable for teams. The discipline is in focusing on customer problems, not every suggested solution. Problems are durable and worth solving; features are just guesses. By anchoring discussions on the underlying problems, product leaders can say “no” without guilt—because the real “yes” is to building solutions that actually matter.
What would you do?
Magic wand
8
.
If you had an extra $1,000,000, where would you put it?
Your response: More marketing and more analysts/auditors
A million dollars sounds like freedom, but without a strategy, it’s just fuel for chaos. Some teams throw money at features no one wanted; others pump it into sales or marketing before the product is ready. The right question isn’t “where can we spend this money fastest?” but “which investments advance our strategy, solve real problems, and create measurable impact?” Without that clarity, the million dollars vanishes—and you’re left with the same issues, only more expensive ones.
Next Steps
Acknowledging the issues is the first step; tackling them with a proven approach is what creates real progress. That’s where we can help. Our experienced coaches work with product leaders and teams to cut through the noise, align on strategy, and make the tough calls about where to invest—or divest.
We bring a structured process for evaluating new ideas, rationalizing product portfolios, and ensuring every decision ties back to business outcomes. With our support, you’ll stop spreading resources thin and start channeling them into the opportunities with the highest impact. You’ll have the confidence to sunset underperforming products, double down on winners, and present a clear vision that reassures executives and customers alike.
In short, we can help you move from reacting to requests to leading with intention—and build a product portfolio that works for your business, not against it.
Free Resources
Balance Ambitious Ideas with Limited Resources

Download this free ebook for a tool to help you balance your portfolio resources across products, markets, and personas.


