GROWTH
The Jungle Book
Mimicking competitors leads to a lost voice
They copied the message with glee,
Thinking it’d work, can’t you see?
But their voice was too plain,
And lost in the main,
Now they’re stuck with no clear identity.
"The Jungle Book" effect, inspired by the song "I Wanna Be Like You," happens when companies mimic their competitors’ messaging instead of carving out their own identity. This approach may seem like a safe bet—if it works for others, it should work for you, right? But this leads to weak differentiation, confusion among potential customers, and a diluted product message that struggles to stand out in the market.
Oh, oobee doo
I wanna be like you
I wanna walk like you, talk like you, too
You'll see it's true, someone like me
Can learn to be like someone like you
Symptoms
Customer Confusion. Users can’t tell the difference between your product and others in the same category. They don’t see a compelling reason to choose your offering over a competitor’s.
Unoriginal Messaging. Your product’s messaging looks and sounds nearly identical to that of your competitors. There’s no unique value proposition that sets you apart.
Chasing Trends. You’re constantly reacting to competitors’ moves, trying to keep up with the latest trends or features rather than focusing on what your product does best.
Inconsistent Brand Voice. The tone and style of your communication shift depending on what’s popular or what the competition is doing, leaving customers unsure about your brand’s identity.
Consequences
Lack of Differentiation. If your product doesn’t stand out, it becomes a commodity. Customers will choose based on price or convenience rather than recognizing your product’s unique value.
Price Pressure. With little to differentiate your product from the competition, you’re forced to compete on price, driving down margins and profitability.
Brand Confusion. Customers may associate your brand with inconsistency, making it harder to build long-term loyalty. They might not remember what your brand stands for.
Missed Opportunities for Innovation. By focusing on what others are doing, you miss the opportunity to innovate and create something truly unique that could capture a new segment of the market.
Recommendations
Develop Your Own Voice. Spend time identifying what makes your product truly unique and valuable. Develop messaging that highlights your differentiators rather than mimicking what’s already in the market.
Stay True to Your Brand. Consistency is key to building a strong brand identity. Ensure that your messaging, tone, and voice align with your brand’s core values and mission, not the latest trend.
Conduct Competitor Analysis, Not Copycatting. Understand what your competitors are doing, but don’t simply mirror them. Use competitor analysis as a tool to identify gaps and opportunities that you can capitalize on to differentiate your product.
Innovate Beyond Messaging. Innovation should go beyond words. Focus on delivering unique features, user experiences, and product benefits that make your product stand out based on its own merits.
Mimicking competitors might seem like a shortcut to success, but it ultimately leaves your product voiceless and your brand undifferentiated. By finding and highlighting your unique value, focusing on customer-centric language, and showcasing your brand’s authentic personality, you can create messaging that stands out and builds a loyal following. Remember, it’s better to be a leader with a clear voice than an echo in the marketplace.
You might like to read
What is a Product?
As a product manager and executive, one of the most frequent and frustrating conversations I had with sales was around the definition of...